Judge ‘troubled’ by Crown evidence against Windsor man charged with dangerous driving
Joseph Mallen, 25, is facing three charges in relation to an accident on Feb. 14, 2019 after his vehicle collided with another at the corner of George Avenue and Reginald Street.
Karen Kelly, 69, died 12 days later, in hospital, from the injuries she suffered.
Mallen is charged with dangerous driving causing death, obstruction of justice and public mischief but has maintained his innocence throughout the court process.
“I’m concerned about the potential for a wrongful conviction,” Justice Renee Pomerance told assistant Crown attorney Jonathan Lall Thursday in Superior Court.
Lall and defence lawyer John Sitter presented their closing arguments to the judge, after a trial concluded on Sept. 22.
Throughout his closing remarks, Lall was interrupted by Justice Pomerance, who repeatedly expressed concerns about reasonable doubt.
“My sense is I can’t determine who the driver was,” Justice Pomerance told Lall. “If I have a doubt, that’s all he (Mallen) need provide.”
At trial, the two passengers in Mallen’s vehicle both testified that Mallen was driving the vehicle at a high rate of speed before he failed to stop at an intersection and collided with Kelly’s sedan.
Lall referred to their testimony as “superior evidence” compared to the version of events provided by several witnesses who only say the aftermath of the crash.
Lall says the two passengers were unknown to each other before the night of the crash and as such had no reason to lie about who was driving the car.
But a defence witness, Brad Jones previously testified he heard Mallen say, “the driver ran! The driver ran!”
Mallen implicated a different person as the driver of the vehicle, saying he was in the backseat of the car that night.
That person also testified at trial, telling the court not only was he not in the vehicle, he had not seen Mallen for days before the night of the accident.
Justice Pomerance however told Lall, “I’m relying on the eyewitnesses because they cast real doubt.”
“As soon as this accident happened Mr. Mallen began this campaign of misdirection,” Lall countered.
Justice Pomerance was also critical of the Windsor Police Service for coming to a “preconceived conclusion” about the alleged driver.
Before court Thursday, Justice Pomerance said she reviewed Mallen’s video statement to police and told the court while she watched it “I could not help but think of tunnel vision.”
Windsor Police initially charged a different man in connection with the accident and Kelly’s death but those charges were withdrawn before Mallen was re-arrested and charged.
About a dozen members of Kelly’s family were in the gallery of the courtroom for the proceedings; many wearing shirts with her picture on the front.
Justice Pomerance directly asked Lall if he believed someone else was driving the vehicle that hit Kelly.
Before the crown attorney could answer a member of Kelly’s family said out loud “No!”, to which Justice Pomerance asked them to refrain from outbursts.
“I know this is difficult to hear,” she said but continued enquiring about the potential of reasonable doubt.
Defence lawyer John Sitter told the court the crown case “does not meet the criminal standard of guilt.”
He argued the court “can’t get around Brad Jones’ (testimony)” of identifying a different person exiting the car from the driver’s seat.
Sitter also argued one of Mallen’s passengers had been drinking and consuming marijuana on the night in question and texting at the time of the accident and hit her head off the dashboard upon impact.
“The weight of her evidence should be suspect,” Sitter argued.
He concluded his closing statement by saying, “there’s reasonable doubt. It would be dangerous to convict.”
Justice Pomerance will deliver her verdict to Mallen on Oct. 31 at 9 a.m. in Windsor’s Superior Court.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
MPP Sarah Jama asked to leave Ontario legislature for wearing keffiyeh
MPP Sarah Jama was asked to leave the Legislative Assembly of Ontario by House Speaker Ted Arnott on Thursday for wearing a keffiyeh, a garment which has been banned at Queen’s Park.
Mountain guide dies after falling into a crevasse in Banff National Park
A man who fell into a crevasse while leading a backcountry ski group deep in the Canadian Rockies has died.
2 teens charged in Halifax homicide: police
Two teenagers have been charged with second-degree murder in connection to an alleged homicide near the Halifax Shopping Centre earlier this week.
'Deep ignorance': Calls for Manitoba trustee to resign sparked after comments about Indigenous people and reconciliation
A rural Manitoba school trustee is facing calls to resign over comments he made about Indigenous people and residential schools earlier this week.
12-year-old hippo in Japan raised as a male discovered to be a female
When Gen-chan arrived at a zoo in Japan in 2017, no one questioned whether the then-five-year-old hippopotamus was a boy. Seven years later, zoo staff made a surprising discovery: Gen-chan, now 12, was female.
Here's why Harvey Weinstein's New York rape conviction was tossed and what happens next
Here's what you need to know about why movie mogul Harvey Weinstein's rape conviction was thrown out and what happens next.
Legendary hockey broadcaster Bob Cole dies at 90: CBC
Bob Cole, a welcome voice for Canadian hockey fans for a half-century, has died at the age of 90. Cole died Wednesday night in St. John's, N.L., surrounded by his family, his daughter, Megan Cole, told the CBC.
Humanist group threatening to sue Vancouver over council prayers
The B.C. Humanist Association has threatened legal action against the City of Vancouver for allowing prayers at council, following a similar warning issued earlier this month to a smaller community on Vancouver Island.
LHSC performs a Canadian first in robot-assisted direct lateral spine surgery
Spine surgery may never be the same for people with chronic back pain and other physical ailments.