Ontario to introduce new animal welfare legislation
A caged cat reaches out it's paw inside the Toronto Humane Society building on Friday November 27, 2009. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chris Young
TORONTO -- A specialized team of provincial inspectors would enforce animal cruelty laws in Ontario under new legislation introduced on Tuesday.
Solicitor General Sylvia Jones said the team would be composed of about 100 inspectors, but she wouldn't say how much the new system would cost.
Jones said the bill -- dubbed the Provincial Animal Welfare Services Act -- would also include stiffer penalties for cruelty offences.
"I believe at the end of the day, we're going to have a stronger model that ensures we have consistency in enforcement across Ontario," Jones told reporters.
Under the bill, there would also be specialists who will deal with livestock, horses and zoos and aquariums. Jones said Crown attorneys would be trained to deal with animal cruelty prosecutions. The new law would go effect on Jan. 1, 2020.
In March, the Ontario Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals told the province it would no longer enforce animal cruelty laws, focusing instead on other endeavours such as its shelter operations.
The move followed a court decision in January that declared the charity's enforcement powers unconstitutional. Justice Timothy Minnema said the province erred when it gave police powers to the charity -- which has enforced the laws on behalf of the province since 1919 -- without imposing reasonable standards of transparency and accountability.
Animal advocates and stakeholders have long spoken about the need for a revamped cruelty enforcement regime in Ontario. Many said Tuesday they were cautiously optimistic about the bill.
"Animal Justice is encouraged by Ontario's announcement that animal welfare enforcement in this province will become a fully public function," said Animal Justice's executive director Camille Labchuk.
"We support a robust, well-funded public enforcement model because animal protection is a key societal value, and this is what Ontarians expect."
Lynn Perrier, the founder of Reform Advocates for Animal Welfare, applauded the move by Premier Doug Ford's government.
"Of particular interest to me is the potential contribution Crown attorneys can make to enforce animal abuse laws," she said. "To date, animals have not been well represented in our courts and abusers get away with a slap on the hand. Hopefully that will end now."
Barbara Cartwright of Humane Canada has long pushed for more training for prosecutors in animal cruelty cases.
"Crown prosecutor training is a breakthrough for Ontario in animal welfare," she said. "It will strengthen relationships between enforcement and Crown leading to more convictions for animal abusers."
Kendra Coulter, a labour studies professor at Brock University, studied the previous OSPCA enforcement regime and spoke to dozens of frontline officers as part of her research. She found in a 2016 report that the majority of officers were poorly paid, worked in the field alone often facing dangerous circumstances, and were responsible for "extremely large geographic regions."
"The framework is promising and thoughtful," she said on Tuesday. "Our research has found that a dedicated publicly funded anti-cruelty team would be the smartest option for Ontario so I am pleased that the government has made this the foundation of its new approach."
The solicitor general also said there will be big fines for corporations found guilty of animal cruelty, including a $250,000 fine for a first-time offence and up to $1 million for repeat offenders.
This story by the Canadian Press was first published Oct. 29, 2019.